Jay’s Substack

Jay’s Substack

Share this post

Jay’s Substack
Jay’s Substack
Arthur Hayes -- The Periphery
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
User's avatar
Discover more from Jay’s Substack
I fucking love crypto
Over 3,000 subscribers
Already have an account? Sign in

Arthur Hayes -- The Periphery

Another one

Jay's avatar
Jay
Oct 25, 2023
7

Share this post

Jay’s Substack
Jay’s Substack
Arthur Hayes -- The Periphery
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
Share

Arthur shares his view (original article) on the bear steepener and the Hamas terrorist attacks – specifically on how these will impact markets. I break down his essay into a summary of 4 parts:

  • Rate Pause

  • Bear Steepener Death Spiral

  • Hamas Attack

  • America’s conundrum

Rate Pause

  • In ‘22, the FED took the strategy of raising rates + quantitative tightening to reduce inflation

  • The FED said that once inflation is low enough (very ambiguous) they would stop

  • Recently in the Sept Fed meeting, Powell said that the FED is close to finishing rate hikes

  • Additionally, we saw longer term rates rise. Members of the FED responded to this as a signal that the Fed no longer needed to raise rates

  • As a result the longer term bond market saw a large sell-off (relative to the shorter term bonds) resulting in a “bear steepener”

    • A bear steepener is when the longer term rates rise faster than the short term

  • Why does this happening?

    • Inflation is still here. “The manipulated US gov inflation stat, core CPI is still more than double the Fed’s target of 2%”

    • If the FED announces it is pausing its fight against inflation, owning long duration bonds presents more risk around its value decaying in real terms

  • Historically, a bear steepener rarely happens. What usually happens is the FED continues raising rates and tightening until something breaks

  • Once a catastrophe happens, the Fed aggressively cuts short term rates, un-inverting the yield curve. This is a “bull steepener”

Clearly, no one wants to hold long term rates

Bear Steepener Death Spiral

  • So why is a bear steepener so dangerous?

  • Banks make money based off the spread between the deposit rate they pay and the loan rate that they issue out

  • A simple example is a mortgage. A 30Y fixed rate mortgage that the bank issues out will carry plenty of risks (simplified)

    • If interest rates go up after the mortgage fixed rate is locked, banks will suffer a unrealized loss on their balance sheet

    • You can hedge interest risk by going short (taking a loan). But then the question of “what duration should the loan be?” comes into play

    • If the duration is too long, and the mortgage is prepaid, the bank is now exposed

    • If the duration is too short, and rates go up, you re-run into interest rate risk

  • Keep in mind, the past 15 years (up until ‘22), interest rates have basically been trending down aggressively and in the last few years were at rock bottom

  • As a result, Arthur thinks that the vast majority of banks long term loans are not hedged properly

  • Long duration bond values also decay exponentially with an increase in rates (e.g. roughly, a 10Y loan will decrease 10% in value for a 1% increase in rates)

  • More concretely, after the GFC in 2008, rates were kept near zero and quantitative easing (central banks printing and buying long bonds to suppress yields)

  • As a result, there was demand for higher yield, and a lot of banks’ fixed income desks sold exotic interest rate products to fulfill this gap

  • To simplify it, these banks are now short volatility wrt to the long term rates

  • As volatility in long term rates go up, these banks will suffer losses

    • In order to hedge this, they would sell long term bonds

  • And now have a nasty bear steepener death spiral

    • As volatility goes up, long term bonds need to be sold to hedge

    • Selling long term bonds increases the volatility

  • MOVE measures the bond volatility and you can see above that it is increasing in correlation with the spread between short vs. long term interest rates

  • In addition to this, the US banking system suffered a crisis back in Mar ‘23. This issue still exists and we can see that US banking system has another 700B in unrealized losses on US treasuries

  • What the market hasn’t come to consensus on is that the entire balance sheet of the US bank is government guaranteed

    • Government guarantee means more $$$ printing (and as a result, increased inflation)

Hamas Attack

  • After the Hamas terrorist attack, the market reaction was:

    • Treasuries rallied (yields fell), gold moved lower, oil slightly higher

  • The immediate narrative was that ppl wanted US debt as a flight to safety

  • The muted reaction of oil showed that the market didn’t believe the conflict would escalated

  • Oil prices rose slightly - which showed that the market didn’t think this conflict would escalated (oil prices go way up during a full blown conflict)

  • Shortly, the Israeli PM issues an aggressive response “Every Hamas terrorist is a dead man” – escalating the war

  • The complication here is that a number of Arab countries (pro Palestine) surround Israel

    • So if Israel decides to strike back, how does America react here? America needs to make a decision on whether to outright support Israel or not

    • Russia and China also have complex relationships with the middle east. If America steps in (or if they don’t), what do they do now?

  • Remember, the US spent 10T on the Afghan, Iran, Syria conflicts in the early 2000s. Biden has stated that he backs Israel. So how far is he willing to go here?

America’s Conundrum

  • Remember, the most important thing in politics is re-election

  • Hamas was terrible for people, but it is bringing people together in stronger support of Bibi politically. As a result, there is pressure on Bibi to respond in a favorable way

  • Israel’s response has already caused lots of innocent Palestinian civilians to be killed

  • Now the ball is in Biden’s court. Is this the sort of behavior that America will support?

  • Biden is stuck here, there is no good option.

    • If he doesn’t support, it will be a sign of weakness of America

    • If he does, it can be taken the wrong way by Russia’s ally Syria (and will force Russia to react)

The market view 360’ed after Israel’s aggressive response
  • After the military response escalated and America stayed silent, the US treasury market continued selling off. Its clear that the market is pricing in the future cost of military support to Israel

  • In either case, if America pours resources into funding the war, that increases net demand which spikes inflation

  • Additionally, you do not want to own long term debt from a sovereign nation that may be involved in multiple state level conflicts (Ukraine, Israel)

Conclusion

  • This is starting to look more and more like “buy hard assets” trigger for Arthur. It’s not the set up he expected, but its one that has a pretty inevitable outcome

  • As Arthur says “the perfect set up is usually staring you right in the face, and you are too preoccupied with the past to notice” — Arthur is starting small but he is bidding

    Jay’s Substack is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.


Subscribe to Jay’s Substack

Launched 2 years ago
I fucking love crypto
The Worker Bee's avatar
Jay's avatar
EtherHog's avatar
Ope's avatar
7 Likes
7

Share this post

Jay’s Substack
Jay’s Substack
Arthur Hayes -- The Periphery
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
Share

Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Q2 outlook
we've ~been~ BACK
Apr 1, 2024 • 
Jay
55

Share this post

Jay’s Substack
Jay’s Substack
Q2 outlook
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
8
why i am very bullish crypto over the next 12 months
data driven
Sep 30, 2024 • 
Jay
25

Share this post

Jay’s Substack
Jay’s Substack
why i am very bullish crypto over the next 12 months
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
4
60,000 - 70,000
A reflection on the last 120 days
Jun 27, 2024 • 
Jay
16

Share this post

Jay’s Substack
Jay’s Substack
60,000 - 70,000
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
1

Ready for more?

© 2025 Jay
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More

Create your profile

User's avatar

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.